X5 diesel

[Lost]

Hey guys
I'm flirting with the idea to get a low millage 2010-11 x5 cpo diesel. I have a M3 but I need more cargo space for my sporting gear.
I tried to do some research but I couldn't find too many long term reviews on it.
So any things that I should pay attention or notorious problems with the Diesel engine?
For the diesel owners, will you do it again?
Thanks.

[Da M3nace]

Originally Posted by Lost

Hey guys
I'm flirting with the idea to get a low millage 2010-11 x5 cpo diesel. I have a M3 but I need more cargo space for my sporting gear.
I tried to do some research but I couldn't find too many long term reviews on it.
So any things that I should pay attention or notorious problems with the Diesel engine?
For the diesel owners, will you do it again?
Thanks.

I traded my M3 for this exact car. I got a used 2k10 x5d with 40k miles. I live in NY and let me tell you, it was the best decision I ever made with a car. The truck is all around great. Of course I miss the M3 but the car is just not suited for this type of snow we are getting hit with this winter. Thankful I have my X5.

[serge1]

The engine itself is solid. The emission system could give problems though. Feds require manufacturers to cover most of it untill 80K miles, and some states require *all* of it covered untill 75K. Had a couple sensors (pre and post catalyst NoX) in my 35d replaced under CA/WA state mandate.
I expect the DPF and EGR system to give me problems closer to 100K miles.
P.S. My vehicle is out of original warranty and I chose not to extend it.

[dubsesd]

i would not trade mine for anything different if i were to do it again. my friend is also a service manager at bmw and recommended it as well. he said they see very little of them in for anything. motors are very solid.

[gobie18]

I had mine for two years and 32k miles. No issues so far, I love it.

[Sylvan Lake V35]

I actually had an M3 guy try to trade me straight across. I wanted too but I just couldn't do it.

[Z@T]

I kept my M3 and just added an X5 Diesel as Family hauler Addition.

Love the Diesel.

[vitiokas95]

I would not go for diesel again. I bought mine with 60 k miles. Had EDR recall, dealer fixed it but something else went wrong. they fixed it again. Then my injectors went bad, paid 5k out of my pocket for new injectors, fuel pump, few sensors etc. Car still runs crapy, low power, bunch of codes active, bad fuel mileage. Nobody can figure out what is wrong with it, even dealer...
If I go with X5 again, it will be 3.5

[serge1]

Originally Posted by vitiokas95

I would not go for diesel again. I bought mine with 60 k miles. Had EDR recall, dealer fixed it but something else went wrong. they fixed it again. Then my injectors went bad, paid 5k out of my pocket for new injectors, fuel pump, few sensors etc. Car still runs crapy, low power, bunch of codes active, bad fuel mileage. Nobody can figure out what is wrong with it, even dealer...
If I go with X5 again, it will be 3.5

Sorry to hear about your troubles. However, looks like biggest the problem is an incompetent service dealer, not necessarily the vehicle.
The root issue, as often with any BMW, could be something cheap and trivial (like bad battery).

Have you asked for help on this (or other) forums regarding your issue? We have very knowledgeable members.

[Brainofjjj]

Have 2 M3s and bought a 12 diesel in December with 16k on it for 44k. I love most aspects of the truck except for the heavy steering. I don't have the adjustable steering and have the sport package. It's incredibly heavy around town and almost ruins the car. Other than that it's been great so far. Towing the e46 to COTA next month with it.

[Z@T]

Originally Posted by Brainofjjj

Have 2 M3s and bought a 12 diesel in December with 16k on it for 44k. I love most aspects of the truck except for the heavy steering. I don't have the adjustable steering and have the sport package. It's incredibly heavy around town and almost ruins the car. Other than that it's been great so far. Towing the e46 to COTA next month with it.

Congrats on the new X. I got mine in December too.

There is something wrong with your steering. Mine is perfect and comparable heavy with the M3.

[texvette]

No -- Only have 3k miles on a 2013 but after talking with BMW of North America, doesn't look good. They said due to low mileage, certain problems will not be
covered in some cases. Told the lady that is small town living. So if go with a
BMW again will be gas or a hybrid. So no would not do diesel again. Main reason
took this one was because of rebates.

Like the way the diesel pulls and even the sound. Just doesn't sound like a vehicle
for limited driving.

[serge1]

Originally Posted by texvette

Like the way the diesel pulls and even the sound. Just doesn't sound like a vehicle for limited driving.

I am not sure I understand. Is there a particular problem occuring when vehicle stays parked for long period of time?

[Capnhook]

We bought ours last month. If you're gonna put 2k+ miles a month on a vehicle, no better purchase! The payback when it's time to trade will be worth it in 24-36 months!